From: hls on

"aarcuda69062" <nonelson(a)sbcglobal.net> wrote in message news:nonelson->
> New Toyota coolant also. No Dexcool, no green, no universal global fits
> all makes. Toyota has one of the best coolant formulas available.
>

*******
I respect your experience and knowledge, but I would like to know if you
have some actual data on that last sentence, or what makes you think this
is true. How is their formula different from others?

From: badgolferman on
hls, 1/23/2010,8:49:52 AM, wrote:

>
> "aarcuda69062" <nonelson(a)sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
> news:nonelson->
> > New Toyota coolant also. No Dexcool, no green, no universal global
> > fits all makes. Toyota has one of the best coolant formulas
> > available.
> >
>
> *******
> I respect your experience and knowledge, but I would like to know if
> you have some actual data on that last sentence, or what makes you
> think this is true. How is their formula different from others?

My understanding is the Toyota coolant does not contain silicates. I
am not entirely sure but have been told silicates tend to cause
buildups and/or deteriote seals.

From: nm5k on
On Jan 23, 8:29 am, "badgolferman" <REMOVETHISbadgolfer...(a)gmail.com>
wrote:
> hls, 1/23/2010,8:49:52 AM, wrote:
>
> > "aarcuda69062" <nonel...(a)sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
> > news:nonelson->
> > > New Toyota coolant also.  No Dexcool, no green, no universal global
> > > fits  all makes.  Toyota has one of the best coolant formulas
> > > available.
>
> > *******
> > I respect your experience and knowledge, but I would like to know if
> > you have some actual data on that last sentence, or what makes you
> > think this is true.    How is their formula different from others?
>
> My understanding is the Toyota coolant does not contain silicates.  I
> am not entirely sure but have been told silicates tend to cause
> buildups and/or deteriote seals.

Neither do the usual aftermarket brands though.
I'm using green prestone at the moment, and it has
no silicates, etc, ad nausium.. I've been running it
for 20-25k miles and see no problems at all.
But.. I would prefer the OEM red stuff.
The only reason I'm using the prestone is because
they were out of the red when I went to buy it at a
local carquest.
I plan to go back to the red on the next flush.
But I'm not going to use the pre-mixed. I'm going
to use the older red concentrate and add my own
distilled water.
I'd never ever use dexcool in a yota... It's a
way different formula compared to yota red, or
even the prestone green for that matter.
The prestone is a lot closer to the yota red, except
for the color.
I also never mix coolants. One or the other after
doing a flush.
But saying all that, I'd have to agree with him.
I'd rather use the OEM red if it's available.
Not that I know it's really any better, but it
was designed for Toyota's, so I would prefer it
simply due to that fact.



From: aarcuda69062 on
In article <a9Gdndmt8sQVY8fWnZ2dnUVZ_vOdnZ2d(a)giganews.com>,
"hls" <hls(a)nospam.nix> wrote:

> "aarcuda69062" <nonelson(a)sbcglobal.net> wrote in message news:nonelson->
> > New Toyota coolant also. No Dexcool, no green, no universal global fits
> > all makes. Toyota has one of the best coolant formulas available.
> >
>
> *******
> I respect your experience and knowledge, but I would like to know if you
> have some actual data on that last sentence, or what makes you think this
> is true. How is their formula different from others?

The Toyota long life coolants are 2-EH free, silicate free, phosphate
free. They utilize molybdates for cavitation protection and since their
products are sold world wide, their coolants are designed to be/are very
tolerant of the various water supplies found.

From an anecdotal experience perspective, I can't remember a single
instance of opening a Toyota cooling system and finding the trash that I
do on other brands that have had comparable maintenance.
From: nm5k on
On Jan 23, 3:26 pm, aarcuda69062 <nonel...(a)sbcglobal.net> wrote:

>
> From an anecdotal experience perspective, I can't remember a single
> instance of opening a Toyota cooling system and finding the trash that I
> do on other brands that have had comparable maintenance.

I saw it on mine, but I don't know if it was still pure red coolant.
I bought the car used.
But it was a mess. Lots of "precipitation". Was coating everything
with a yucky sludge looking stuff. Almost to the point of gelling,
but not quite there at the point I noticed it.
That's why I flushed and replaced mine. But it is quite possible
some space cadet mixed another brand coolant with the original red.
I'm kind of thinking someone mixed coolants because instead of
the usual red color, it was more of a yucky brown color.
I checked it not too long ago to see how the Prestone was
holding up, and it looked quite good. So while I'd prefer the yota
red,
I see no signs that the Prestone has any real problems being used
in a Toyota. It's been about two years, and it's still clean and
green.
But I plan to go back to red the next flush.